
True Confession: I have a library problem. A BIG problem! Like a 44 Books Checked Out problem. Partly because it seems to just happen that a bunch of holds come in at the same time, but largely because I can’t resist browsing the bookshelves and adding to my growing collection.
Then I get home and I add them to my mountain of a TBR pile and promptly start to feel overwhelmed. Then, when it’s time for a new read I cautiously approach the pile and spend an hour browsing through all the books trying to decide what to read next. I like to read and rate the first sentence of all the books and choose the one that intrigues me the most.
It can take ages to narrow it down to the ‘winning’ book. I look for a first sentence that beguiles me, leaves me with a question or sparks intrigue. A sentence that makes me want to read more. So I did that today after I came home from my third library visit this week (I just can’t stay away!) And I spent way too long winnowing down my first sentence hopefuls only to become stymied by indecision when I pared the pile down to seven books. Groan! (And, yes, I could have read a whole book with the time I’ve spent trying make this monumental decision!)
So, I had a brilliant idea! Why don’t I let YOU choose my next read for me? Just read the seven first sentences below and and vote for the one you find most appealing in a comment. I’ll tally the answers up and the sentence with the most votes will be the book I read next. And I’ll be able to return at least one book to the library next week! Yay! 🙂
Nine PM and time for me to head to bed…with a book, of course! So I thought I’d update these first sentences with their matching titles in case some of you won’t be able to sleep tonight for not knowing! Bwahahaha!
This Great Water will be my sepulcher.
Tempest at Annabel’s Lighthouse by Jaime Jo Wright
It was a strangely calm morning in March, with no wind off the dales, when the woman I assumed to be my mother slipped into the shop.
The Curious Inheritance of Blakely House by Joanna Politano
So this is how it feels to be near death and utterly alone.
Indigo Isle by T.I. Lowe
Bleak. The weather, her mood, her life.
The Seaside Homecoming by Julie Klassen
What had I done?
The Vanished by Cara Putman
Strange how an empty room could be haunted by sound, especially a sound as whispery and distant as the shiff of sand between the bowls of an hourglass.
The Atlas of Untold Stories by Sara Brunsvold
I was only eight years old when my aunts cursed me.
Truth Cursed by Angie Dickinson
Questions, I Have Questions (and a Giveaway)
- I’m curious: are you a library user? How many books do you have checked out at time?
- How do you choose what will be your next read?
- Do you pay attention to the lure (or not) of first sentences?
And, of course there’s a giveaway.
Leave your vote (#1-#7) in a comment below and join in the conversation to be entered in a draw for:
- US – $10 Baker Bookhouse e-gift card
- Canada – $10 Amazon or Indigo e-gift card
Draw will be held and winner announced on
Saturday October 18 2025.



















