We all know that I am a self-confessed cover snob, but did you know that I am just as opinionated about book titles? It makes sense, in a way, since both title and cover make up a reader’s first impression. Some titles entice me immediately, while others leave me indifferent, confused, even cringing. So I thought it would be fun to chat about our title preferences because I’m sure I’m not the only reader with opinions! 🙂 And stick around to the end for the giveaway announcement.
My Title Dislikes
(Titles used as examples are made up by me, any similarities to real titles of published works is completely coincidental)
Titles that list every trope in the book:
The Billionaire’s Second Chance at Love : Fake Dating His Secret Baby’s Mama
I get that the author/publisher is trying to grab a reader’s attention to make a sale BUT surely they understand that we know how to read a synopsis on the back of the book or online? If you want to emphasize tropes, make them a tag line at the beginning or end of the synopsis and get more creative with the title!
Titles that read like a review:
Millicent Finally Gets Her Man : a well-written, emotionally gripping love story featuring an enemies to more romance guaranteed to stir your heart and curl your toes.
Talk about oversell! If an author has to 5 star review a book in the title, it’s immediately downgraded in my mind. I’m assuming the intention is to make a sale, but it has the opposite effect on me. I wouldn’t even give the back book blurb a chance! ( I know, I’m such a title snob!)
Titles that read like a synopsis:
Lad, a stray dog searches for a family all his own and along the way helps a mother cat find her lost kitten only to discover that her humans might be the right furever family for him as well.
Bwahahaha! My example is a bit (!) extreme, but I’m sure you’ve all seen titles that tell way too much. This would be an automatic no go for me even though I love dogs and the premise of the story is appealing…just not as a title!
Series that have books will similar titles.
Book One: Heat, Book Two: Scorch, Book Three: Burn
I can totally accept that this is unique to Kav issue, but when a series has similar titles, especially when paired with similar cover art, I always get confused and can’t remember which one I’ve read. So, when I’m browsing online or at the library I’ll often bypass these books, promising myself I’ll check my records later but I usually forget. 🙂
My Title Likes
Pun-y titles
Owl’s Well That Ends Well (actual title in the Meg Langslow series)
One of the delights of cozy mystery reading are all the pun-y titles. So many wonderful options and I’m amazed that authors/publishers are still creating new ones!
Along that line – titles that play on words, especially when they are a twist on classic literature
Sense and Suitability (actual title!)
So clever! It immediately draws me in and I start to wonder how the author is going to reimagine elements from a well-loved story.
A title that’s intriguing on it’s own but once you’ve read the book, you realize how aptly it suits the story.
Hearts in Circulation (actual title!)
Librarian heroine with a bookmobile finds romance on the road. 🙂 This is one of my favourite titles because it matches the story perfectly and there’s hidden layers that fit too!
A title that sparks my imagination
Forgotten
When I read a book with a title like this my mind goes all over the place. What is forgotten? Does the heroine feel forgotten? Does a main character have amnesia? Is there a mystery around something that has been forgotten? A character with dementia? A family history that needs to be uncovered? So many directions the story could take and I want to be in at the very start!
Giveaway Opportunity:
US – paperback or ebook
Canada – paperback, ebook or audible (if available)
International – ebook if you have a US Kindle account
Time to put your thinking caps on and share your title likes and dislikes in a comment or email (kavluvstoread AT yahoo DOT ca) but this time, add in the intriguing title of a book you would like to win if your name is drawn. Books must be Christian Fiction and already published.
Draw will be held and winner announced on Saturday December 6 2025