Category: Book Review

There’s a lot going on in Joy Howard’s life. She’s got an ex-husband who starts acting like he doesn’t want to be an ex anymore, a sixteen-year-old daughter in need of a guiding hand and a lot of rides to dance practice, more orders for paintings than she has time to paint, and a roster of tutoring clients who sometimes need far more than she can give.

What she doesn’t have is time for a new relationship.

Samuel Bo Beauman is a lot of things. He’s a counselor for transitioning ex-cons, a good friend to many, a construction worker, a brother and son, and even a part-time model for a high-end sportswear catalog. He’s also a man searching for redemption.

One thing he isn’t is a man in need of a girlfriend.

But none of that seems to matter when Bo hears Joy’s kind voice in a crowded coffee shop. He instantly knows she’s someone he wants to know better. The two of them hit it off–much to the dismay of practically everyone they know–but Bo doesn’t care what other people think. He feels at peace whenever he’s with Joy, and he won’t let her go without a fight.

When Joy starts getting mysterious texts and phone calls from unknown numbers, she tries to ignore it. But instead of going away, the messages escalate and Joy realizes she can’t handle it alone. But she is juggling a jealous ex-husband, a handful of students with little to lose, and a brand-new boyfriend who spent several years behind bars. Who can she trust?

My Review:

I’m not sure how I feel about the series (Rumors n Ross County.) It’s definitely not the sweet romance I’ve come to expect from Shelley Shepard Gray. It’s like a whole different genre. Still great storytelling, but edgier and the books feel more like general market fiction. I definitely feel that the first book, Edgewater Road, had way more questionable content than this one did. Sycamore Circle is very much ‘toned down’ and I appreciate that but…

Bo is all alpha male with a side of Southern charm that both compliments and contradicts. An ex-con who serves other ex-cons by helping them acclimate to life on the outside. He’s definitely rough around the edges and there were a couple of scenes that made me uncomfortable. Plus there’s a bit of crude language which is par for the course, given the men and their backgrounds, I guess.

Joy is his exact opposite. A straight-laced, by-the-books single mom (with a sixteen year old daughter) who is the older woman who steals Bo’s heart. We’re not told how much older she is — she’s thirty-six. It felt like a lot of their relationship was based on physical attraction and, Bo in particular, was pretty forward in his pursuit of the, understandably, more hesitant Joy which sometimes crossed barriers for me as he relentlessly (albeit politely) pursued her. He never crossed any lines, but sometimes it just felt off for me.

Aside from their romance, there’s a bit of a stalker suspense thread featuring Joy as the victim. There’s also drama with her ex-husband — so lots for Bo to get all alpha male protective over and I enjoyed the rising tension that hits midway through the story until the frantic climax.

There’s also a secondary plot featuring Joy’s daughter and an Amish boy who is thinking about leaving his community which added an interesting twist to the overall story.

There was one major subplot that remained unresolved by the end of the book — not sure if it will be picked up in book three, but it doesn’t seem likely since the epilogue for Sycamore Circle is set a year later and the unresolved issues were time sensitive and would have played out by then so….I’m left with way too many questions, like why that thread was added to the story towards the very end and then just fizzled out?

For all my misgivings, I did find Sycamore Circle a compelling read. I never considered putting it down, but it did leave me feeling a bit unsettled after I finished. And, having said that, I am intrigued enough by another ex-con character who is also ex-Amish that I am really hoping there’s a third Rumors in Ross County and it will feature Seth’s story.